I'm not sure on brands. Your best bet is someone who works in the parts department of a local marina before you go to the boat store. He might have some opinions on what are the best brands. You can use the pitch and size of your original and just alter the material it's made of or the number of blades. If you want to get jiggy with it, follow the suggestions in the article for tweaking it.
Here are five top brands of props for 2018 from the Marine Lab website:
Turning Point Aluminum, 4 blades
Turning Point 31501931 Stainless Steel 4 blades
Quicksilver Nemesis Aluminum 4 blades
Mercury Black Max 3 Aluminum 3 blades
MotorGuide Machette III Aluminum 3 blades